研究概要
我们展示了 ML-NMR 在时间至事件结局中的应用,并介绍了可用于辅助实施的代码。鉴于其优势,当需要为多种治疗的比较进行人群调整时,我们鼓励从业者使用 ML-NMR。
研究思路结论见上方概要
目的
多水平网络meta回归(ML-NMR)利用个体患者数据(IPD)和来自随机对照试验(RCTs)网络的聚合数据,评估多种治疗的比较疗效,同时调整研究间差异。我们提供了针对时间至事件结局的ML-NMR概述,并将其应用于一个示例性案例研究,包括示例R代码。
方法
本案例研究评估了idecabtagene vicleucel(ide-cel)、selinexor+dexamethasone(Sd)、belantamab mafodotin(BM)和常规治疗(CC)对三类暴露的复发/难治性多发性骨髓瘤患者在总生存期方面的比较疗效。单臂临床试验和真实世界数据被简单合并,以创建聚合数据人工随机对照试验(aRCT)(MAMMOTH-CC对比DREAMM-2-BM对比STORM-2-Sd)和IPD aRCT(KarMMa-ide-cel对比KarMMa-RW-CC)。在一些假设下,我们纳入了呈偏态分布的连续协变量,以中位数和范围报告。ML-NMR模型对既往治疗线数、三类难治状态和年龄进行了调整,并使用留一信息准则进行比较。我们在IPD aRCT人群中总结了预测风险比和生存率(95%可信区间)。
结果
Weibull ML-NMR模型的留一法信息准则最低。在总生存期方面,ide-cel比Sd、BM和CC更有效。效应修饰因子对模型影响极小,仅三类难治是预后因素。
展开英文摘要原文
OBJECTIVES
Multilevel network meta-regression (ML-NMR) leverages individual patient data (IPD) and aggregate data from a network of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to assess the comparative efficacy of multiple treatments, while adjusting for between-study differences. We provide an overview of ML-NMR for time-to-event outcomes and apply it to an illustrative case study, including example R code.
METHODS
The case study evaluated the comparative efficacy of idecabtagene vicleucel (ide-cel), selinexor+dexamethasone (Sd), belantamab mafodotin (BM), and conventional care (CC) for patients with triple-class exposed relapsed/refractory multiple myeloma in terms of overall survival. Single-arm clinical trials and real-world data were naively combined to create an aggregate data artificial RCT (aRCT) (MAMMOTH-CC versus DREAMM-2-BM versus STORM-2-Sd) and an IPD aRCT (KarMMa-ide-cel versus KarMMa-RW-CC). With some assumptions, we incorporated continuous covariates with skewed distributions, reported as median and range. The ML-NMR models adjusted for number of prior lines, triple-class refractory status, and age and were compared using the leave-one-out information criterion. We summarized predicted hazard ratios and survival (95% credible intervals) in the IPD aRCT population.
RESULTS
The Weibull ML-NMR model had the lowest leave-one-out information criterion. Ide-cel was more efficacious than Sd, BM, and CC in terms of overall survival. Effect modifiers had minimal impact on the model, and only triple-class refractory was a prognostic factor.
CONCLUSIONS
We demonstrate an application of ML-NMR for time-to-event outcomes and introduce code that can be used to aid implementation. Given its benefits, we encourage practitioners to utilize ML-NMR when population adjustment is necessary for comparisons of multiple treatments.
论文信息
- 作者
- Maciel D、Jansen JP、Klijn SL、Towle K、Dhanda D、Malcolm B、Cope S
- 第一作者单位
- PRECISIONheor, Evidence Synthesis and Decision Modeling, Vancouver, BC, Canada.Canada
- 通讯作者单位
- PRECISIONheor, Evidence Synthesis and Decision Modeling, Vancouver, BC, Canada. Electronic address: shannon.cope@precisionvh.com.Canada
- 文献类型
- 网状荟萃分析 · 非美国政府资助研究
- 期刊
- Value in health : the journal of the International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research2024 Aug