研究概要
NK细胞疗法显示出指示性的早期经济信号,值得进一步的临床和经济研究。微观成本核算识别出可操作的制造成本驱动因素,为工艺优化提供信息,这些探索性估计为随着临床证据发展而进行的迭代经济评估奠定了基础。
研究思路结论见上方概要
目的
自然杀伤(NK)细胞疗法是一种有前景的用于实体瘤的同种异体、现货型免疫疗法,但目前缺乏指导其临床转化的经济学证据。本研究旨在对其生产进行微观成本分析,并从澳大利亚卫生系统视角对NK细胞疗法用于儿童实体瘤进行探索性经济学评价。
方法
采用主要实验室生产数据,对六个生产步骤和类别进行了微观成本核算分析。住院费用通过专家意见估算。效果估计值取自嵌合抗原受体(CAR)-T细胞疗法的经济学评价。分析包括增量成本效果比(ICER)、余量分析、净货币效益(NMB)和概率敏感性分析。
结果
每批次的生产成本为 AUD 58 681(USD 38 143)(每剂 AUD 9780;USD 6357)。88% 的成本集中在三个步骤:NK 细胞扩增(50.8%)、mRNA 转染(25.1%)和 T 细胞去除(11.7%),其中耗材/试剂占生产总成本的 85%。将生产费用(AUD 58 681)和住院费用(AUD 75 000;USD 48 750)合并计算,每名患者的 NK 细胞治疗总成本为 AUD 133 681(USD 86 893),基于替代疗效估计,得出的示意性 ICER 为每获得一个 QALY 需 AUD 35 167(USD 22 859)。每名患者的经济余量为 AUD 56 386(USD 36 651)。概率分析显示,在 AUD 50 000/QALY 阈值下,具有成本效益的概率为 51.7%,最低需要 2.67 个 QALY。
展开英文摘要原文
OBJECTIVES: Natural killer (NK) cell therapy is a promising allogeneic, off-the-shelf immunotherapy for solid tumors, yet economic evidence to guide its clinical translation is absent. This study aimed to conduct a micro-costing analysis of their manufacturing and perform an exploratory economic evaluation of NK cell therapy for paediatric solid tumors from an Australian health system perspective.
METHODS: A micro-costing analysis was conducted using primary laboratory production data across six manufacturing steps and categories. Hospitalisation costs were estimated by expert opinion. Effectiveness estimates were drawn from chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-T cell therapy economic evaluations. Analyses included incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs), headroom analysis, net monetary benefit (NMB) and probabilistic sensitivity analysis.
RESULTS: Manufacturing cost was AUD 58 681 (USD 38 143) per batch (AUD 9780; USD 6357 per dose). Eighty-eight per cent of costs were concentrated in three steps: NK cell expansion (50.8%), mRNA transfection (25.1%) and T-cell depletion (11.7%), with consumables/reagents comprising 85% of the total production cost. Combining manufacturing (AUD 58 681) and hospitalisation (AUD 75 000; USD 48 750) costs, the total NK cell therapy cost was AUD 133 681 (USD 86 893) per patient, yielding an illustrative ICER of AUD 35 167 (USD 22 859) per QALY gained, based on a proxy effectiveness estimate. Economic headroom was AUD 56 386 (USD 36 651) per patient. Probabilistic analysis showed 51.7% probability of cost-effectiveness at AUD 50 000/QALY, with a minimum of 2.67 QALYs required.
CONCLUSION: NK cell therapy shows indicative early economic signals warranting further clinical and economic investigation. Micro-costing identifies actionable manufacturing cost drivers to inform process optimisation, and these exploratory estimates provide a foundation for iterative economic evaluation as clinical evidence develops.
论文信息
- 作者
- Wahid ST、Elliott M、Wang Y、Nicholls W、Omer N、Souza-Fonseca-Guimaraes F、Tuffaha H
- 第一作者单位
- Centre for the Business and Economics of Health The University of Queensland Brisbane QLD Australia.Australia
- 通讯作者单位
- School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences The University of Queensland Woolloongabba QLD Australia.Australia
- 期刊
- Clinical & translational immunology2026